A multifamily syndication is a private partnership formed to buy a single apartment property. A general partner sources, finances and operates the asset and is compensated by fees and a share of profit above a hurdle. Limited partners contribute most of the equity, own units in the partnership rather than the building itself, take no part in management, and sit behind the lender in the capital stack. The interests are securities, offered under an exemption from registration rather than reviewed by any regulator.

Start here

Multifamily syndication: structure and what you own

Ricardo Sanabria, Founder & CEO

Published Last updated

Share

The word gets used loosely enough to be unhelpful. A syndication is a specific legal structure with specific consequences for what you own and where you stand when things go wrong.

What a syndication is

A multifamily syndication is a group of investors pooling capital in a single legal entity, usually a limited liability company or limited partnership, to buy an apartment property that none of them would buy alone. One party organizes and operates it. The rest supply most of the money and make no operating decisions.

The structure is old and unremarkable. What makes it consequential for an individual investor is that the interest you receive is a security, sold without registration under an exemption, which means nobody at any regulator has reviewed the property, the projections, the sponsor or the terms. The SEC describes what a private placement is and is not, and the short version is that the disclosure protecting you in a public offering is absent by design.

The trade is straightforward. You get access to an asset class with a scale requirement you cannot meet individually, professional operation, flow-through tax treatment and leverage on institutional terms. You give up control, liquidity, and the disclosure standard of a registered offering. Whether that is a good trade depends on the sponsor, the terms and your own circumstances, in that order.

Who is who

Five roles appear in almost every deal and conflating them causes most of the confusion in early conversations.

The sponsor, or general partner. Finds the property, negotiates it, raises the equity, signs the loan, forms the entity, executes the business plan and decides when to sell. In exchange they take fees and a promote, which is a share of profit above a hurdle. They are the investment.

The limited partners. You. You contribute capital, receive distributions and an allocation of tax items, and have limited liability. You do not manage. In most agreements your voting rights are narrow, often confined to matters such as removing the general partner for cause or approving a sale outside the stated parameters.

The key principal or guarantor. Frequently overlooked and worth asking about. Agency and bank lenders require someone to sign a recourse carve-out guarantee and to meet net worth and liquidity tests. That person may or may not be the sponsor, and where a third party is paid to provide the balance sheet, their interests are not necessarily aligned with yours.

The property manager. Operates the asset day to day. Sometimes third party, sometimes an affiliate of the sponsor. An affiliated manager is common and not improper, but it is a related-party transaction and should be priced and disclosed as one.

The lender. Not a passive party. Loan covenants shape what the partnership can do, when it must sell, and whether cash can be distributed at all.

The lifecycle, and where you enter it

Understanding the sequence tells you what is already fixed by the time you see a deal, which is more than most investors assume.

The sponsor sources a property, negotiates a purchase and sale agreement, and puts down earnest money. They then conduct due diligence, which is where physical inspection, unit walks, lease audit, environmental and title work happen, and where the price is sometimes renegotiated. They arrange debt. Only then do they open the equity raise, which is where you appear.

That ordering matters. By the time you receive an offering, the purchase price is agreed, the loan is largely structured, the business plan is written and the timetable is running against a contractual closing date. You are being asked to accept or decline a package, not to shape it. The negotiating leverage in a syndication sits almost entirely before the investor arrives.

After closing comes the operating period: renovation if any, lease-up, quarterly reporting, distributions. Then a decision point, usually a refinancing or a sale, which is where the promote is earned and where the hold period frequently extends beyond what was projected, for reasons set out in liquidity and hold periods.

The four documents, and what each one is for

You will be sent a package and asked to sign quickly. Four documents do different jobs and only one of them is a summary.

The private placement memorandum. The disclosure document. Its most useful section is the risk factors, which are written by lawyers to protect the sponsor and therefore contain the most candid statements in the entire package. Read them as a list of what the sponsor believes could go wrong, because that is what they are.

The operating or limited partnership agreement. The contract. This governs everything the marketing does not: the distribution waterfall, whether the preferred return is cumulative, capital call provisions and the consequence of declining, transfer restrictions, the sponsor's removal, fees, and what happens on a sale. Where the summary and this document differ, this document wins.

The subscription agreement. Your offer to buy, containing representations you are making about yourself. You are signing statements about your accredited status, your understanding of the risks and your ability to bear loss. Those representations have consequences.

The investor questionnaire. How the sponsor establishes your accredited status. Under Rule 506(b) this is generally sufficient. Under Rule 506(c) it is not, and documents or a third-party letter will be required, as set out in 506(b) versus 506(c).

If you read one thing properly, read the operating agreement. If you read two, add the risk factors.

Where the money goes

Money enters at three points and leaves at more than most investors count.

On acquisition, investor equity and loan proceeds fund the purchase price, closing costs, an acquisition fee to the sponsor, financing costs including any interest rate cap, and initial reserves and renovation capital. A meaningful portion of what you subscribe is therefore not the property.

During operations, rental income pays operating expenses, then debt service, then capital expenditure and reserves, then the asset management fee, and what remains is available for distribution through the waterfall. Reserve funding is often at the sponsor's discretion and sits above everything, so a property can earn cash and distribute none.

On sale, proceeds repay the loan, then transaction and disposition costs, then flow through the waterfall: return of capital, preferred return, any catch-up, then the split. The order is the whole game, and it is set out in preferred return and the waterfall.

The number worth asking for is not any single fee but the proportion of the sponsor's total expected compensation, in the base case, that comes from fees rather than promote. Fees are paid regardless of outcome. Promote is not. Ours are at what we charge and when.

What actually goes wrong

The risks that materialize are rarely the exotic ones. Four categories account for most of the damage.

Capital structure. Floating rate debt that repriced, an interest rate cap that expired and cost a multiple to replace, a maturity arriving when the property no longer supports the same loan. This is the leading cause of loss in recent years and it is knowable in advance from the loan terms.

Execution. Renovation costs more or takes longer, rent premiums do not materialize, or the assumed rate of unit turnover proves optimistic. The tell is usually an assumption in the model that is stated but never justified.

Market. Supply arrives, employment softens, insurance reprices, or taxes reassess sharply on sale. Some of this is forecastable and some is not, which is why we publish where we would not buy in the market guides.

Sponsor. Inexperience, thin reporting, misalignment, or in rare cases misconduct. This is the one you can most reduce in advance, and the method is in how to vet a sponsor.

Distributions can be suspended, hold periods extend, capital may be called, and you can lose the entire amount. These are not remote scenarios and any one of them can occur in a deal that eventually performs well.

Whether it fits you

The structural facts imply a fairly narrow profile, and it is more honest to state it than to leave you to infer it.

This suits capital that is genuinely long-dated, at a scale where a five to seven year lock-up plus an extension changes nothing else in your life. It suits an investor with a marginal tax rate high enough that flow-through depreciation matters, though the shelter is limited because rental losses are generally passive under IRS Publication 925. And it suits someone willing to read an operating agreement and ask uncomfortable questions of a person they like.

It suits poorly anyone who may need the money, who wants a daily price, who will not do sponsor diligence, or for whom this would be a large share of net worth. For those cases a listed vehicle is a more defensible answer, and the comparison is in syndication versus REIT.

The most common mistake is not choosing the wrong deal. It is choosing the right deal at the wrong size.

Our position

We sponsor these, so read the above as an interested account and check it against the SEC and IRS sources listed below rather than against us.

What we will give you before you subscribe is the property and its address, the rent roll and trailing twelve months, the loan terms including maturity and any rate cap strike and expiry, the full fee stack, our co-investment in dollars, the waterfall including whether the preferred return is cumulative, the capital call provisions and the consequence of declining, and the assumptions we are least confident about.

What we will not tell you is that this is safe, that the projection is a forecast, or that our record predicts anything. The shorter version of the diligence is nine questions before wiring, and the mechanics of your reporting are in reading your Schedule K-1.

Before you wire

What to establish about the structure

  1. May I see the operating agreement and the risk factors before I am asked to sign anything?
  2. Who signs the loan guarantee, are they part of your team, and are they paid for it?
  3. Is the property manager an affiliate, and how was its fee benchmarked?
  4. What proportion of your total expected compensation in the base case is fees rather than promote?
  5. What are the loan terms: fixed or floating, maturity, rate cap strike and expiry, and covenants?
  6. Which assumption in your model are you least confident about?
  7. What entity name should I search on EDGAR for your prior Form D filings?
Sources

What this is built on

  1. Investor.gov, Private placements under Rule 506(b) and 506(c)
  2. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Rule 506(b) of Regulation D
  3. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Rule 506(c) of Regulation D
  4. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Form D, notice of exempt offering of securities
  5. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Rule 144, selling restricted and control securities
  6. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, 17 CFR 230.501, definitions and terms used in Regulation D
  7. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, 17 CFR 230.506, including the paragraph (d) disqualification provisions
  8. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 541, Partnerships
  9. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 925, Passive Activity and At-Risk Rules
  10. Internal Revenue Service, Schedule K-1 (Form 1065), Partner's Share of Income, Deductions, Credits
Ricardo Sanabria, Grey Oaks Multifamily

Ricardo Sanabria · Grey Oaks Multifamily

Answering

Follow-up questions people ask after reading this.

Is a syndication regulated?

The offering is, in the sense that it must satisfy an exemption under Rule 506 and file a Form D notice. The investment is not reviewed. Nobody at the SEC examines the property, the projections, the fees or the sponsor, and a Form D filing is a notice rather than an approval.

Ricardo Sanabria, Grey Oaks Multifamily

What is the difference between the sponsor and the general partner?

In practice they are the same party. Sponsor is the industry term for whoever organizes and operates the deal; general partner or managing member is the legal role they hold in the entity, carrying management authority and the promote.

Ricardo Sanabria, Grey Oaks Multifamily

Which document should I actually read?

The operating agreement, then the risk factors in the private placement memorandum. The agreement governs the waterfall, capital calls, transfers and removal, and it prevails over any summary. The risk factors are the most candid pages in the package.

Ricardo Sanabria, Grey Oaks Multifamily

Who signs the loan?

Not you. A key principal or guarantor signs recourse carve-outs and must meet the lender's net worth and liquidity tests. Sometimes that is the sponsor and sometimes a third party paid to provide a balance sheet, whose interests may differ from yours. Ask which.

Ricardo Sanabria, Grey Oaks Multifamily

Does all my money go into the property?

No. Subscriptions also fund closing costs, an acquisition fee, financing costs including any interest rate cap, renovation capital and initial reserves. Ask for the sources and uses table, which shows exactly where it goes.

Ricardo Sanabria, Grey Oaks Multifamily

Can I get my money out early?

Realistically no. The interest is a restricted security requiring a holding period of at least a year for a non-reporting issuer before resale would be lawful, the agreement generally requires sponsor consent to transfer, and there is no practical market of buyers.

Ricardo Sanabria, Grey Oaks Multifamily

What usually goes wrong?

Capital structure, more than operations. Floating rate debt repricing, an interest rate cap expiring, or a maturity arriving when the property no longer supports the same loan. Those terms are all disclosed before you invest if you ask for them.

Ricardo Sanabria, Grey Oaks Multifamily

How much should I invest?

An amount that could stay committed for the projected hold plus two to three years, through suspended distributions and a possible capital call, without affecting anything else. Sizing is where most avoidable damage happens.

Ricardo Sanabria, Grey Oaks Multifamily

8 questions

Start an investor inquiry →
Related

Keep reading